Six drones fly in three lanes $3\ \text{m}$ apart: three start on the west side and three on the east, and each must cross to the opposite side of its own lane, so every drone meets another head on. They cruise at $2\ \text{m/s}$ and can tilt at most $30ยฐ$.
Every drone follows the same separation rule: within the separation radius $R$ of another drone, it brakes, steers away and veers right (as boats do), more strongly the closer it gets.
Choose $R$ so that no two drones ever come within $1\ \text{m}$ of each other, while every drone still ends within $0.3\ \text{m}$ of its landing spot.
Principles it rests on
Relative motion: two drones flying at each other at $v$ close at $2v$.
The rotors only push along the drone's axis, so the horizontal acceleration is limited by the tilt: $a_{max} = g\tan\theta_{max}$.
Braking distance from speed $v$: $d = v^2/(2a)$.
Reaction distance: a drone must first tilt before it can brake, covering ground meanwhile.
Question
What separation radius $R$ keeps the swarm safe while still letting every drone land on its spot?
Your setup must satisfy
West 1 never comes within 1 m of another drone
East 1 never comes within 1 m of another drone
West 2 never comes within 1 m of another drone
East 2 never comes within 1 m of another drone
West 3 never comes within 1 m of another drone
East 3 never comes within 1 m of another drone
West 1 ends within 0.3 m of its landing spot
East 1 ends within 0.3 m of its landing spot
West 2 ends within 0.3 m of its landing spot
East 2 ends within 0.3 m of its landing spot
West 3 ends within 0.3 m of its landing spot
East 3 ends within 0.3 m of its landing spot
Drag to orbit ยท scroll to zoom ยท right-drag to pan
Your settings
Hints
Solution
Step 1: Closing speed Head on, each at $2\ \text{m/s}$: they close at $4\ \text{m/s}$.
Step 2: Reaction distance A drone has to tilt before it can brake, which takes about $0.2\ \text{s}$. Meanwhile the pair closes $$4 \times 0.2 = 0.8\ \text{m}$$
Step 3: Braking distance At most $a = g\tan 30ยฐ = 9.81 \times 0.577 = 5.7\ \text{m/s}^2$ each: $$d = \frac{v^2}{2a} = \frac{2^2}{2 \times 5.7} = 0.35\ \text{m per drone}, \quad 0.7\ \text{m for the pair}$$
Step 4: Smallest radius The rule only starts acting at distance $R$, and the drones must stop $1\ \text{m}$ apart: $$R \gtrsim 0.8 + 0.7 + 1.0 = 2.5\ \text{m}$$
Step 5: Largest radius At their landing spots, drones in neighbouring lanes are $3\ \text{m}$ apart. If $R > 3\ \text{m}$ they keep pushing each other off their spots and never settle. So $$2.5\ \text{m} \lesssim R < 3\ \text{m}$$
Answer: $R \approx 2.5$ to $3\ \text{m}$, e.g. $2.6\ \text{m}$, where the closest approach is $1.32\ \text{m}$. The simulation passes from $2.4$ to $3.0\ \text{m}$. At $2.2\ \text{m}$ two drones come within $0.70\ \text{m}$, and at $3.1\ \text{m}$ the drones crowd each other at the landing spots. The starting $1\ \text{m}$ is far too small, and the drones collide.
The general lesson: a swarm's safety distance has to grow with its speed. Doubling the cruise speed doubles the reaction distance and quadruples the braking distance.
How others did
Nobody has tried this yet.Be the first. Your answer starts the stats.
Only each person's first answer, given before viewing the solution, is counted.
Discussion 0 comments
Log in to join the discussion.