Omniadisce

Transcona grain elevator, 1913

Lesson Beginner

Join free to take this lesson

Anyone can look around, but taking a lesson needs a free account. With one, your answers are checked step by step and your progress is saved, so you can stop and pick up where you left off on any device.

4 steps ยท about 15 min ยท runs in the Soil lab

A grain elevator tipped over in one piece in a day. The soil had not had time to drain.

The idea

Near Winnipeg, October 1913. A new concrete grain elevator, a long block of bins on a single raft, was being filled for the first time. Within a day it tilted to about 27ยฐ and sank into the ground on one side. Nobody was hurt.

It stood on a thick deposit of clay. Loaded quickly, clay cannot drain: it fails in undrained shear, with a strength $c_u$, and the bearing resistance is about $(\pi + 2)\, c_u + \gamma D$, whatever the width.

The numbers here are simplified: one 8 ร— 8 m block of bins on 4 m of soft clay (c_u = 30 kPa) over stiff clay, loaded with grain to about 125 kPa.

By the end you can

  • Clay loaded quickly fails with its undrained strength $c_u$: bearing โ‰ˆ (ฯ€ + 2) c_u + ฮณD.
  • Clay is weakest just after loading; it strengthens as it drains.
  • Foundations on weak clay go down to firmer ground.

Discussion 0 comments

Log in to join the discussion.

× Enlarged view