A solid ball ($m = 0.45\ \text{kg}$, radius $r = 0.1\ \text{m}$) is putted along level grass. It rolls from the start, without skidding. The grass resists rolling with a coefficient of rolling resistance $C_{rr} = 0.06$: while the ball rolls, the ground exerts a torque $C_{rr}\,N\,r$ against its rolling, where $N$ is the normal force.
The green runs from $3.6\ \text{m}$ to $4.8\ \text{m}$ from the ball. Choose the putt speed so that the ball comes to rest on the green.
Principles it rests on
Rolling without slipping: $v = \omega r$, so $a = \alpha r$.
Rolling resistance: a torque $\tau_{rr} = C_{rr}\,N\,r$ opposes the rolling, with $N = mg$ on level ground.
Newton's second law for translation ($ma = f$) and for rotation about the centre, with static friction $f$ at the contact linking the two.
Moment of inertia of a solid ball: $I = \tfrac{2}{5} m r^2$.
Constant deceleration: $v^2 = 2 a d$.
Question
At what speed must the ball be putted to stop on the green?
Your setup must satisfy
The ball comes to rest on the green (3.6โ4.8 m)
The ball has stopped by the end
Drag to orbit ยท scroll to zoom ยท right-drag to pan
Your settings
Hints
Solution
Step 1: Deceleration of a rolling ball Take the direction of motion as positive. Static friction $f$ at the contact acts on the motion: $m a = f$. About the centre, the spin changes under the torque of friction and the rolling-resistance torque, which both act against the spin here: $$I\,\frac{a}{r} = -f\,r - C_{rr}\,m g\,r$$ using $\alpha = a/r$ for rolling without slipping. Substituting $f = m a$: $$a\left(\frac{I}{r^2} + m\right) = -C_{rr}\,m g \quad\Rightarrow\quad a = -\frac{C_{rr}\, g}{1 + I/(m r^2)} = -\frac{C_{rr}\, g}{1 + 2/5} = -\frac{5}{7}\,C_{rr}\,g$$ Part of the resistance goes into slowing the spin, so a ball slows less than $C_{rr}\,g$ would suggest. $$|a| = \frac{5}{7} \times 0.06 \times 9.81 = 0.420\ \text{m/s}^2$$
Step 2: Speeds for the green $$d = \frac{v^2}{2|a|} \quad\Rightarrow\quad v = \sqrt{2 |a|\, d} = \sqrt{0.841\, d}$$ $$d = 3.6\ \text{m}: \ v = 1.74\ \text{m/s}, \qquad d = 4.8\ \text{m}: \ v = 2.01\ \text{m/s}$$
Answer: a putt speed between about $1.75$ and $2.0\ \text{m/s}$, e.g. $1.88\ \text{m/s}$, which stops at $1.88^2/0.841 = 4.20\ \text{m}$, the middle of the green. The simulation agrees: $1.88\ \text{m/s}$ stops at $4.19\ \text{m}$.
Why the starting value fails: $1.5\ \text{m/s}$ stops after $1.5^2/0.841 = 2.7\ \text{m}$, well short of the green.
Mass and size do not matter: both $m$ and $r$ cancel. A heavier or bigger solid ball on the same grass rolls exactly as far. A hollow ball ($I = \tfrac{2}{3} m r^2$) would slow at $\tfrac{3}{5} C_{rr} g$ and roll further.
How others did
Nobody has tried this yet.Be the first. Your answer starts the stats.
Only each person's first answer, given before viewing the solution, is counted.
Discussion 0 comments
Log in to join the discussion.