Step 1: Friction$$f = \mu m g = 0.3 \times 20 \times 9.81 = 58.9\ \text{N}$$
Step 2: How far does it slide?While pushing ($t_p = 0.6\ \text{s}$): $a_1 = (F - f)/m$, reaching $v_1 = a_1 t_p$ after travelling $\tfrac{1}{2} a_1 t_p^2$.
After the push friction stops it over $v_1^2 / (2\mu g)$. Total:
$$s = \tfrac{1}{2} a_1 t_p^2 + \frac{(a_1 t_p)^2}{2 \mu g}$$
Setting $s = 0.5\ \text{m}$ gives $a_1 \approx 1.75\ \text{m/s}^2$, so you need $F \gtrsim 58.9 + 20 \times 1.75 \approx 94\ \text{N}$.
Step 3: Torques about the centre of mass while slidingTake "tipping forward" as positive.
- The push at height $h$: $\tau_F = F\,h$ (forward if $h > 0$, backward if $h < 0$).
- Friction acts at the floor, $0.8\ \text{m}$ below the centre, pointing backwards: $\tau_f = 0.8\,f = 47.1\ \text{Nยทm}$, also forward.
- The normal force $N = mg = 196\ \text{N}$ can shift at most $w/2 = 0.3\ \text{m}$ from the centre, so it can supply at most $N \times 0.3 = 58.9\ \text{Nยทm}$ of correcting torque in either direction.
Step 4: No-tipping condition$$-58.9 \le F\,h + 47.1 \le 58.9 \quad\Rightarrow\quad -106\ \text{Nยทm} \le F\,h \le 11.8\ \text{Nยทm}$$
Pushing high ($F h$ large and positive) tips the crate forward. Pushing low and hard ($F h$ below $-106\ \text{Nยทm}$) tips it backwards: the push turns the bottom forward faster than friction allows.
Step 5: A working answer$F = 150\ \text{N}$ at $h = 0$: $F h = 0$, within the window, and $a_1 = 4.56\ \text{m/s}^2$ gives $s \approx 2.1\ \text{m} \ge 0.5\ \text{m}$. ? (The simulation measures $1.98\ \text{m}$ with a tilt under $0.1ยฐ$.)
The full answer space: any $F \gtrsim 94\ \text{N}$ with $-106/F \le h \le 11.8/F$ (in metres). For example $F = 100\ \text{N}$ allows $h$ up to about $+0.12\ \text{m}$; $F = 200\ \text{N}$ needs $-0.53\ \text{m} \le h \le +0.06\ \text{m}$.
Why the starting values fail: $F = 250\ \text{N}$ at $h = 0.6\ \text{m}$ gives $F h = 150\ \text{Nยทm} \gg 11.8\ \text{Nยทm}$, so the crate tips forward.
Discussion 0 comments
Log in to join the discussion.