Omniadisce

Is Thomson's lamp on or off?

Multiple choice Intermediate New no attempts yet

A lamp has a single button that switches it between on and off. At $t = 0$ the lamp is on.

After $1$ minute you press the button. After another $\tfrac12$ minute you press it again, then after another $\tfrac14$ minute, then $\tfrac18$, and so on, halving the wait each time.

The waits add up to $1 + \tfrac12 + \tfrac14 + \dots = 2$ minutes, so infinitely many presses are done by $t = 2$ minutes. The philosopher J. F. Thomson described this lamp in 1954.
Principles it rests on
  • A sequence that keeps alternating, such as $1, 0, 1, 0, \dots$, has no limit.
  • Grandi's series $1 - 1 + 1 - 1 + \dots$ diverges: its partial sums alternate between 1 and 0.
  • A description of every moment before a time $T$ does not, on its own, fix what happens at $T$.
Question
What state is the lamp in at exactly $t = 2$ minutes?

Sources & evidence

  1. Thomson's lamp: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomson%27s_lamp
  2. Supertasks (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy): https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/spacetime-supertasks/
  3. Grandi's series: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grandi%27s_series
Nobody has tried this yet.Be the first. Your answer starts the stats.

Only each person's first answer, given before viewing the solution, is counted.

Discussion 0 comments

Log in to join the discussion.

× Enlarged view