The states before 2 minutes. Write 1 for on and 0 for off. After $0, 1, 2, 3, \dots$ presses the lamp is in state
\[ 1, 0, 1, 0, 1, 0, \dots \]
These are exactly the partial sums of Grandi's series $1 - 1 + 1 - 1 + \dots$. The sequence keeps alternating, so it has no limit and the series has no sum.
Why a limit can't settle it. When the values of an infinite process converge, such as the positions of a body covering a convergent series of distances, the limit tells us the state when the steps end. Here the states don't converge, so there is no value that continuity could hand on to $t = 2$.
Thomson's argument and the reply. Thomson argued that the lamp must be on or off at 2 minutes, yet neither answer is possible, so a supertask (completing infinitely many actions) is impossible. Paul Benacerraf replied in 1962 that the story only fixes the lamp's state at every time before 2 minutes. The state at $t = 2$ is a separate fact that the story doesn't mention, so on, off, or even a broken bulb are all consistent with it. There is no contradiction, only a missing piece of information.
A tempting wrong answer. Grandi's series can be given the value $\tfrac12$ by Cesร ro averaging, the average of its partial sums. That is a summation convention, not a physical state, and it doesn't make the lamp "half on".
So the description doesn't determine the lamp's state at $t = 2$.
Discussion 0 comments
Log in to join the discussion.