Omniadisce

Can a flying arrow be at rest at every instant?

Multiple choice Intermediate New no attempts yet

Zeno's arrow paradox goes like this.

At any single instant, a flying arrow occupies a region of space exactly its own size. Within that instant there is no time for it to move, so at that instant it is at rest. But time is made up of instants, and the arrow is at rest at every one of them. So the arrow never moves, and motion is an illusion.

Suppose the arrow's tip is at $x(t) = 50t$ metres at time $t$ seconds.
Principles it rests on
  • Velocity at an instant is defined as a limit: $v(t) = \displaystyle\lim_{h \to 0} \frac{x(t+h) - x(t)}{h}$.
  • Rest and motion are not properties of a single instant on its own. They depend on where the object is at neighbouring instants.
  • Motion is being at different places at different times (Russell's "at-at" theory of motion).
Question
Which step of Zeno's argument does calculus reject?

Sources & evidence

  1. Zeno's paradoxes (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy): https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/paradox-zeno/
  2. Derivative: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derivative
Nobody has tried this yet.Be the first. Your answer starts the stats.

Only each person's first answer, given before viewing the solution, is counted.

Discussion 0 comments

Log in to join the discussion.

× Enlarged view