Omniadisce

How many balls are left in the vase at noon?

Multiple choice Intermediate New no attempts yet

You have an empty vase and an endless supply of balls numbered $1, 2, 3, \dots$
  • At 1 minute to noon you put balls 1 to 10 in the vase and take ball 1 out.
  • At $\tfrac12$ minute to noon you put balls 11 to 20 in and take ball 2 out.
  • At $\tfrac14$ minute to noon you put balls 21 to 30 in and take ball 3 out.

You carry on like this, halving the time each step: at step $n$ you put in the next ten balls and take out ball $n$. Infinitely many steps are done by noon. (This puzzle is due to J. E. Littlewood and Sheldon Ross.)
Principles it rests on
  • The limit of the counts is not always the count of the limit: sizes don't have to be continuous.
  • A ball is in the vase at noon only if it was put in and never taken out.
  • Two processes with the same counts at every step can end with different results.
Question
How many balls are in the vase at noon?

Sources & evidence

  1. Rossโ€“Littlewood paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ross%E2%80%93Littlewood_paradox
  2. Supertasks (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy): https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/spacetime-supertasks/
Nobody has tried this yet.Be the first. Your answer starts the stats.

Only each person's first answer, given before viewing the solution, is counted.

Discussion 0 comments

Log in to join the discussion.

× Enlarged view