Follow any ball. Ball $n$ is put in at step $\lceil n/10 \rceil$ and taken out at step $n$, which comes no earlier. Both steps happen before noon. So every ball that ever enters the vase has left it by noon, and the vase is empty.
For example, ball 37 goes in at step 4 and comes out at step 37.
Why the counts mislead. After step $n$ the vase holds balls $n+1$ to $10n$, which is $9n$ balls. This grows without limit. But each particular ball is eventually removed, so the set of balls left at noon is empty. The number of balls is not continuous: the limit of the counts ($\infty$) is not the count at the limit ($0$).
Which balls matters. Change one detail: at step $n$, take out ball $10n$ instead of ball $n$. The counts are the same, $9n$ after step $n$. But now balls $1$ to $9$, $11$ to $19$, and so on are never removed, so infinitely many balls are left at noon. The answer depends on which balls leave, not just on how many.
A philosophical caveat. Like other supertask puzzles, the story only describes moments before noon. The answer "none" assumes that a ball is in the vase at noon exactly when it went in and was never taken out. Most mathematical treatments accept that assumption. Some philosophers argue the story leaves noon undetermined, or that the setup can't happen physically at all.
Discussion 0 comments
Log in to join the discussion.