Omniadisce

How should a beam fail?

Lesson Beginner

Join free to take this lesson

Anyone can look around, but taking a lesson needs a free account. With one, your answers are checked step by step and your progress is saved, so you can stop and pick up where you left off on any device.

5 steps ยท about 15 min ยท runs in the Concrete lab

If a beam must fail, it should fail slowly and visibly. Engineers design for that.

The idea

A beam can fail in bending (bars yield, cracks open wide, it sags a lot: plenty of warning), in shear (a diagonal crack near a support, sudden) or by crushing of over-reinforced concrete (sudden).

Shear is carried by the concrete and by links (stirrups) that stitch diagonal cracks: $V_{Rd,s} = \frac{A_{sw}}{s} z f_{ywd} \cot\theta$ with $z = 0.9d$ and $\cot\theta = 2.5$.

Good design makes bending the weakest link, so a failing beam always warns the people under it.

By the end you can

  • Bending failure is slow and ductile; shear failure is sudden.
  • Links hold diagonal cracks shut: $V_{Rd,s} = A_{sw}/s \cdot z f_{yd} \cot\theta$.
  • Good design makes bending the weakest link.

Discussion 0 comments

Log in to join the discussion.

× Enlarged view